Butter Olives with Pits (Castelvetrano)

$46.47  / 3pk

With a reputation as the best tasting olive in the world, Butter Olives' mild, crisp and buttery taste make them our #1 most popular whole olives. Please note, these Castelvetrano green olives contain pits.

  • Castelvetrano olives naturally fermented in salt water brine.
  • Loaded with 4 billion CFUs of lactobacillus per serving.
  • One package contains 16 ounces, equaling one full pint of green olives with pits plus brine.
Select Your Frequency
Select Your Flavor
Start Building Your Box

Buy more and save!

  • 3 Items

    $15.49 / item
  • 15% Off

    6 Items

    $13.17 / item
  • 25% Off

    9 Items

    $11.62 / item
  • 30% Off

    12+ Items

    $10.84 / item

You might also like

  • Locally Sourced

    We source most of our vegetables from local farms. That means just a day or two between harvest and fermentation. This preserves phytonutrients and creates a more nutritious product.

  • Salt Water Brine

    We use mineral-rich, pure and unrefined Mediterranean sea salt. It’s non-iodized and contains no caking agents or added preservatives.

  • Zero Vinegar or Sugar

    Pickles containing vinegar or sugar are not lactic acid fermented and therefore are not a probiotic, gut-healthy pickle. Period.

  • Illustration of happy beneficial bacteria

    Raw & Unpasteurized

    Some call it ‘wild fermentation’ because it creates an abundant growth of natural, live probiotics. Pasteurization would kill these live cultures, so we don’t do it.

Our Quality Promise

Olives icon Olives icon Olives icon
Hands chopping fresh ingredients at a cutting board

Fermented olives are nutrient dense, whole foods.

Serving Size: 6 olives
Servings Per Container: 6
Amount Per Serving: 46 Calories
%DV
4.2g
14%
0.6g
2%
0g
0mg
0%
294mg
13%
2.5g
4%
1.3g
6%
0mg
0g
0%
0.3g
0
0mg
21%
0mg
1%
0mg
4%
0mg
17%

Castelvetrano olives (with pits), high mineral sea salt, filtered water

Hands chopping fresh ingredients at a cutting board

OLIVE MADNESS

“I've never met an olive I don't like. After trying Olive My Pickle olives, true love has bloomed.”

David C.

GARLIC AND OLIVES

"Garlic Stuffed Olives really offer all of the best benefits of olives and garlic at the same time. I really do like the garlic flavor - it isn't overwhelming. These are good olives."

Marv

UNIQUE AND WONDERFUL

"All of my life I've loved all olives, but I've never tasted olives like this. They're firmer and more flavorful than other olives I've enjoyed. I will certainly buy more!"

Anne J.

OLIVE HEAVEN

"I have died and gone to olive heaven! The Butter Olives are to die for! I don't even like olives... until these!!"

Laura A.

5 STARS

"I honestly HATED olives until I tried Olive My Pickle olives. These are definitely my favorite. I'm surprised just how much I like olives now... Well GOOD olives."

Trish S.

VERY TASTY OLIVES

"Such a great deal for the big bundle of olives, and the tastiest olives! I let everyone who visits have a few olives. They have delicious flavors."

Gina T.

The "new" superfoods.

(Well, not quite new. But definitely super.)

A bowl with an assortment of fresh and pickled vegetables with a smaller bowl of dip in the center

Immune Boosting

The rich lactic acid bacteria in ferments is scientifically validated to support immune system function.

Nourishing

The high prebiotic fiber content in fermented veggies feeds and nourishes the resident microbiome.

Energizing

Live enzymes in ferments help to digest food, which increases the body’s energy levels.

Hydrating

Made with sea salt rich in minerals potassium and sodium, these electrolytes hydrate the body at a cellular level.

Nutrient Density

Fermentation enhances nutrients through its metabolic process, boosting B vitamin levels especially.

Verified

Third party tested & verified to contain billions of colony forming units of lactobacillus per serving.

Subscribe & Save Big

Save money and never run out of your favorites.

Subscribe & Save Big Now
Illustration of Olive My Pickle box

Choose 100% of the
products in your box.

Pick your
delivery schedule.

Illustration of a calendar in front of a pickle truck

Save BIG when you subscribe, get the best deal we’ve got!

Subscribe & Save Big Now

How to Eat Fermented Foods

It's a lifestyle, not a fad or a phase.

Consistently eating probiotic foods over the course of your life is the key to optimal results. A serving size, 3 times a day is about right.

Mix it up.

Consume an abundant variety of ferments. Each one has a unique microbial profile and your gut thrives on this biodiversity.

Breakfast. Lunch. Dinner. Snacks.

Because 70% of your energy is spent on digestion, when you eat ferments with meals, their enzymes aid this process. The result is more energy for you.

FAQs

Are olives fermented?

Yes, olives are technically fermented, but the term generally used for this is ‘cured or ‘brined. ’ Our olives are distinct because they are not pasteurized and therefore maintain their live culture status. 

Which types of probiotic bacteria are in olives?

Live culture olives contain 4 billion colony forming units (CFUs) of lactic acid bacteria per serving. A serving is about 6-8 olives. The most abundant types of probiotic bacteria found in live culture olives are Lactobacillus Plantarum and Lactobacillus Pentosus.

What are the health benefits of live culture olives?

Real, salt-water brined, live culture olives contain naturally occurring probiotics that are optimal for gut health. Olives contain healthy Omega 3 fats, an abundance of antioxidants and many more health benefits. 

Not to brag, but people really love us.

4.9
Rated 4.9 out of 5 stars
Based on 142 reviews
Total 5 star reviews: 131 Total 4 star reviews: 7 Total 3 star reviews: 3 Total 2 star reviews: 0 Total 1 star reviews: 1
97%would recommend this product
Slide 1 selected
Write a Review (Opens in a new window)
142 reviews
  • gilbert c.
    Verified Buyer
    I recommend this product
    Rated 5 out of 5 stars
    9 months ago
    good olive

    nice taste and great flavor

    Was this helpful?
  • Bridget H.
    Verified Buyer
    I recommend this product
    Favorite time to enjoy it? Snack
    Rated 5 out of 5 stars
    1 year ago
    Bought a cute container for my butter olives!

    Delicious Olives and it comes in a cute pouch but now my dispenser will make them even easier to devour!

    Was this helpful?
  • Willie W.
    Verified Buyer
    I recommend this product
    Favorite time to enjoy it? Breakfast, Lunch, Dinner, Snack
    Rated 5 out of 5 stars
    2 years ago
    Love the olives

    They go great by themselves and your other products.

    Was this helpful?
  • Kate M.
    Verified Buyer
    I recommend this product
    Rated 5 out of 5 stars
    3 years ago
    5 Stars

    Olive My Pickles’ products are my new go-to snack! I have thoroughly enjoyed the Kosher Dill Pickles, Carrot + Dill Kraut and Butter Olives. I love to add chopped Butter Olives to some whole grain Sorghum tossed with a little olive oil. I believe eating your fermented products for the last week has turned my health around. I thank you, from the bottom of my gut! Just ordered more today so I can keep eating fiber, fermented food and fat 3x a day!

    Was this helpful?
  • jodi k.
    Verified Buyer
    I recommend this product
    Rated 5 out of 5 stars
    12 seconds ago
    So good

    Perfect buttery flavor. I love them.

    Was this helpful?